Steve Storkan and Aaron Dean report that ESOPs distributed $141.8 billion to participants from 2009 through 2024, using Form 5500 filings. They argue cumulative payouts belong alongside plan counts, participants, and assets. The total excludes 401(k) hybrid plans, so it is conservative.
Steve Storkan, Executive Director of the Employee Ownership Expansion Network, authored this October 2026 data study. Aaron Dean of Deanalytics led the data collection and analysis. The study uses federal Form 5500 filings for plan years 2009 through 2024 to measure what employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) have paid out to workers, and it adds six company case studies.
- Study method: The analysts reviewed every pension plan Form 5500 filing for 2009 through 2024. A plan counted as an ESOP when it reported pension characteristic codes 2O, 2P, or 2Q. Plans reporting codes 2J or 2K were excluded because they can include employee salary deferrals.
- Distributions over time: Annual payouts began near $4.5 billion in 2009. They reached $14.9 billion in 2024, the highest year in the series. Average yearly payouts were about $8.8 billion.
- Contributions: The same plans reported about $76.9 billion in contributions. Contributions rose every year from 2017 through 2024, reaching about $8.1 billion in 2024. The study says contributions and distributions should not be compared as investment returns.
- Terminated plans: Plans in the termination process paid out about $28.7 billion, or roughly one dollar of every five distributed. Large plans filing Schedule H supplied 74.8 percent of that total. Small plans filing Schedule I supplied 25.2 percent.
- Plan counts: The study identified 3,943 new ESOPs and 3,839 ESOPs entering termination. From 2016 through 2024, new ESOPs exceeded terminations by a cumulative 568 plan events.
- Large plan cases: Entertainment Partners, Dynetics, and Lifetouch each produced payouts near or above $1 billion. Entertainment Partners was acquired by TPG in 2019. Dynetics was acquired by Leidos for about $1.65 billion. Lifetouch was sold to Shutterfly.
- Small plan cases: Taylor & Martin paid $204 million in 2024, with another $90.7 million still to be distributed. Gypsum Supply Company paid about $101 million. Owensboro Specialty Polymers paid about $52 million, and Borchers Americas acquired it in 2017.
- Lifetouch outcome: The Lifetouch sale was followed by litigation, facility closures, and workforce reductions. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed dismissal of the amended complaint in 2020. The study uses this case to show that a large payout does not answer every question about what happens next.