All three are forms of broad-based employee ownership, but they differ in cost, complexity, and mechanics. An EOT holds the company in trust for employees, who do not buy their own shares; it tends to cost less to set up and is more flexible than an ESOP, but in the United States the selling owner gets no special capital-gains break (Canada's rules differ). An ESOP is a regulated retirement plan with higher setup and compliance costs; a C-corporation owner who has held the shares for at least three years, sells at least 30% to it, and reinvests the proceeds in qualified replacement property can defer capital-gains tax under Section 1042. A worker cooperative is directly member-owned and governed one-member-one-vote, and a sale to a qualifying worker cooperative can use the same Section 1042 deferral on the same three conditions.
Employee Ownership Trusts (EOTs), ESOPs, and worker cooperatives are the three main forms of broad-based employee ownership. They share the goal of putting ownership in employees' hands, but they work differently.
Employee Ownership Trust (EOT)
- The company is held in a trust for the benefit of employees. Employees do not buy their own shares, so there is no out-of-pocket cost to them.
- Setup costs are relatively low and the structure is flexible: you can tailor governance, profit-sharing, and the pace of the transition (including partial sales).
- No special capital-gains treatment for the selling owner. The gain is taxed under the normal rules, though a seller-financed sale can often spread that tax over the note payments. The company can generally deduct the profit-sharing it pays, which employees are taxed on as ordinary compensation.
ESOP (Employee Stock Ownership Plan)
- A federally regulated retirement plan (ERISA) that holds company stock for employees, with higher setup and ongoing compliance costs, including an annual independent valuation.
- Section 1042 deferral is conditional: the company must be a C corporation, the ESOP must own at least 30% after the sale, the seller must have held the shares for at least three years, and the proceeds must be reinvested in qualified replacement property within the set window. S-corporation sellers cannot use it today; from 2028, SECURE 2.0 lets them defer tax on up to 10% of the sale.
- For S corporations, the share of profits owned by the ESOP is generally not subject to federal income tax, a significant ongoing advantage.
Worker cooperative
- Directly member-owned; employees become member-owners and typically govern one-member-one-vote.
- Members usually make a modest buy-in. The cooperative can deduct qualifying patronage distributions, and a seller can use the Section 1042 deferral only if the co-op meets the tax-code definition of an eligible worker-owned cooperative and the same C-corporation, 30%, and holding-period conditions are met.
Which fits best depends on company size, entity type, the owner's tax situation and goals, and how much governance change the team wants. These are US rules; UK reliefs differ. This is general education, not legal or tax advice; confirm the specifics with a CPA or an attorney experienced in employee-ownership transitions.